What psychology has to say about victim blaming

Victim blaming and slut-shaming are common practice when lay-people (and otherwise) attempt to account for situations of sexual violence. So much so that comments such as those made by a Toronto Police officer who suggested that women should avoid ‘dressing like sluts’ to avoid being victims of rape, have sparked the recent SlutWalk movement.

Some interesting findings from social cognition researchers suggest that victim blaming might be a particularly common error in judgment. It seems that people are much more likely to focus on behaviours that they view as controllable when thinking about a particular outcome. As an example, Khaneman and Tversky (1982) asked participants to imagine a scenario in which Mr. Jones was killed by a young driver under the influence of drugs. In one version, they were told that he took an unusual route home from work that day; in the other, he took the same route he always takes. Participants who thought he was killed taking the unusual route were both more upset and more likely to complete “If only…” statements such as “If only he had taken his usual route” (rather than remove the intoxicated individual from the scene). Presumably, it seems that the ‘route taken’ was the more controllable variable.

Findings such as this suggest that people often attempt to mentally undo actions by focusing on things that are deemed more controllable, such as the victims behaviour. Just like the drunk driver in the previous example, the same counterfactual thinking may apply to instances of rape. Since we can readily generate counterfactuals (what could, should, or might have been) on the part of the victim of rape (if only she had taken a different route home, if only she hadn’t drank so much, if only she was wearing something different…), we might be more likely to focus on the victim’s behaviour rather than the perpetrator.

However, this also reveals a bias toward conceptualizing rapist’s behaviour as uncontrollable and has implications for the way we think about male sexuality more generally. We often hear ‘she was asking for it’ or ‘she was wearing a short skirt’ which always suggests that the victims behaviour is the thing to be controlled. Male sexuality, on the other hand, is never questioned. It is assumed to run rampant and be dangerously out of control and therefore, not blameworthy. If I may extrapolate further from the drunk-driver example, these studies reveal more than just how we think about counterfactuals (what could, should, or might have been) but reveal deeply embedded cultural biases about what we view as controllable or not. And implicitly, what is to be controlled.

About littlemissnomer

Quite simply, just another human being frustrated with the absurd and oppressive messages that limit our full humanity and constrain our views of reality in ways that preclude collective action for social change.
This entry was posted in Psychology and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to What psychology has to say about victim blaming

  1. jba says:

    “Male sexuality, on the other hand, is never questioned. It is assumed to run rampant and be dangerously out of control and therefore, not blameworthy.”

    Uhm… how about we switch “male” to “rapist”. Women rape men too, and the victims don’t even get blamed, they get laughed at and disregarded.

    • You are right. Women do rape men as well. I guess it is as much of a problem to think that male = rapist as it is to think that female = she was asking for it. I get that. I do think, however, that male sexuality is very much defined (socially) as uncontrollable, and thus implicitly, akin to a rapists’. This is why sexism and male dominance is bad for everyone and the point which I intended to make. I am definitely not trying to cast all men as rapists.

      • jba says:

        Agreed, sexual discrimination works against EVERYONE. I was just kind-of irked that an author who is trying tear down gender roles mistakenly reinforces them.

    • Wes says:

      ”What about the menz”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s